a project of LOOK Up DETROIT,
a nonprofit outreach of communication and compassion
The challenge of ‘The 99% Problem’
A mismatch of resources?
“Some want to live within the sound of church or chapel bell,
I want to run a rescue shop within a yard of hell”
– Pioneer evangelist C. T. Studd
From the Web Evangelism Website:
It’s almost like there’s a rule: 99% to us, 1% for them. We can see it reflected in Christian bookshops, where a search of the book titles and videos will reveal that the vast majority of material is produced entirely for Christians, in terms of language, content and underlying assumptions. Just how many books and videos are truly evangelistic and accessible to unchurched people who do not know the language and the concepts? We can see it often reflected in churches’ support or awareness for evangelism outside their own countries, in particular the needs of the non-Western world.
And the situation is the same online. The overwhelming majority of Christian websites are aimed at Christian readers.
Please don’t misunderstand me. We Christians need teaching, discipleship, encouragement, and it is a wonderful blessing to have these things so accessible online. I praise God for the many resources which are ministering to the Body of Christ worldwide, providing accessible 24/7 support and blessing.
But the lack of truly evangelistic websites in the English language (let alone other languages) is tragic. The situation becomes clearer if we understand the process by which people become Christians, as described by the Gray Matrix.
If you are not familiar with the Engel Scale and its very helpful modification, the Gray Matrix, check the Matrix page to understand how it is possible to broadly identify the spiritual position of a person or a whole population.
Then study the Mismatch Chart below. On the vertical side, you will see a range of spiritual understandings as defined in the Engel Scale. Set against these are percentages of people at any particular point on the scale, and of Christian media effectively targeting them, in a typical country.
The left-hand yellow shading displays the percentage of people within a typical population, on each position on the Engel Scale. You can see that at any one time, only a small number of people are at the point of commitment. More people are at +2, +3 and +4 because those are positions of slower movement. Less people are at +5 because of course, not all Christians make it to real maturity.
The red shaded area indicates the percentage of websites (and other media) which actually effectively relate to people at each level of the Engel Scale. Of course, carefully produced sites and other media can target a range of levels.
We see clearly that only a tiny percentage of Christian sites and other media are successfully targeting those people with no knowledge of the Gospel. More of them are available to explain the Gospel to an inquirer, but the bulk are all busy ministering to the needs of believers.
This is the scale and challenge of the ‘99 per cent problem’.
Why the problem?
Here are some possible causes.
Some Christians may perhaps believe that any type of Christian material is somehow evangelistic through a ’trickle-down’ effect. And of course, it is true that non-Christians will sometimes find sites that are aimed at Christians (even such as this one). Even a page on, for example, “My favorite Moody and Sankey hymns” may get an occasional non-Christian visitor. But we do not propose that as a useful strategy for an evangelistic page. I have never yet found by accident a website which would entice me to have any interest in, say, hockey.
We often have so little meaningful contact with non-Christians that we forget how they think and what their needs are. It is very easy to have a ghetto mentality and it becomes much easier to stick to what we know – ministering to other believers. In fact, Jesus took as his starting point for ministry felt needs rather than spiritual needs, and everyday stories rather than scriptural exposition.
We also may assume that non-Christians can easily understand the evangelical jargon we know so well. In fact, the only ones who do understand it are those with a Christian background. We may therefore manage to reach ‘once-churched ’ people with some success, but fail to communicate with the ‘un-churched ’. This partial success will in fact mask the fact that we are only touching a limited section of people – as the Gray Matrix can help us to visualize.
Research suggests that in many societies, about 2% of the population at any one time are particularly open to the Gospel. Expressed in terms of the Gray Matrix or Engel Scale, such people are near the line of decision and have already come to understand the issues and challenges of the Gospel. These are the sort of unusual people who may drop in to a church service unasked, visit a Christian bookstore looking for spiritual help, or start reading an old childhood Bible. God has been calling them, and they are responding. They have probably ‘moved up’ the Gray Matrix following previous exposures to the Gospel, prayers of Christian friends, or major life-changes which have challenged their thinking. Many may also have a church background.
The command of Jesus was not “wait for people to come to you”, but “go out and find them”. Success in reaching the 2% may blind us to the fact that we are not reaching the rest. That will be much harder – see the short story Emlyn and the Far Ponds. Online or offline, it will require creative strategies. Conventional ‘Christian’ websites will not often relate to them – indeed will not usually even be found by them.
It may be more difficult for evangelistic agencies to raise finance and support for ‘virtual’ online evangelism, as compared with face-to-face ministry. And of course, an online evangelistic site is free, where as production of evangelistic tracts or videos does create income.
Community pages are an amazing strategy for online outreach which very few people are yet using. (We are doing it at LookUpDetroit.com) The concept is to create a site based on the local community – town, local area/county. The site must offer the best secular links for the community in a range of categories. It must be a genuinely useful resource at this level. But it also contains appropriate Christian links in various categories. READ MORE
Visit our Metro Portal at LookUpDetroit.com
Checkout the many community posts coming into our Metro Blog at LookUpDetroit.net
Under Creative Commons License: Attribution
440 Burroughs Street # 629 – Detroit, MI 48202
Look Up Detroit
a nonprofit outreach of communication and compassion